MATURE

 

Most Spot-On Portrayal Of Leonardo

1. Soulcatcher by hummerhouse  Rated: M

2. Night Addictions by Goblin Cat KC  Rated: T

3. Trap by hummerhouse  Rated: M

​

 

Most Spot-On Portrayal Of Raphael

1. Prey by hummerhouse  Rated: M

2. Logic of the Soul by Poetique823  Rated: T

3. Rock Your World by RandomMel85  Rated: M

 

Most Spot-On Portrayal Of Donatello

1. Freak Show by Fever To Write & CJtheStoryteller

2. Whole Again by GorrillazObsessor  Rated: E

3. Lure by hummerhouse  Rated: M

 

Most Spot-On Portrayal of Michelangelo

1. Candles Drowning by Goblin Cat KC  Rated: M

2. So, I guess….we all have issues by SpectrumWriting  Rated: T

3. Bait by hummerhouse  Rated: M

​

Vilest Villain

1. Fixing Donnie by lukeyandlou (ThePsychologist)  Rated: M

2. One’s True Instincts by sampsonknight (Donatello)  Rated: M

3. Freak Show by Fever to Write & CJtheStoryteller (Deacon)  

3. Stranger Under My Skin by jkathurricane2813 (Nak’ir)  

 

Most In-Character Portrayal Of A Canon Ally

1. April’s Gambit by hummerhouse (April)  Rated: T

1. Fixing Donnie by lukeyandlou (Casey)  Rated: M

2. Don's Guide to the Galaxy by FirebirdScratches and turtle-sketches (Jhanna)  Rated: M

3. TMNT 100 Theme by Applepye (Leatherhead)  Rated: E

​

Most Interesting OC

1. Cold Fire Rising by BlueLotusMoon (Hecate)  Rated: T

2. Don's Guide to the Galaxy by FirebirdScratches and turtle-sketches (Klaxor)  Rated: M

3. TMNT Have Dinner With Me by mysteryred (Denim)  Rated: M

 

Most Action-Packed Battle Sequences

1. Both my knees by Pebr  Rated: M

2. Stealth and Sacrifice by GoblinCatKC  Rated: T

3. When The Bough Breaks by EmilyGrace18  Rated: T

3. Gates of Summer by theherocomplex  Rated: T

 

Funniest Lewd Comedy

1. Plumbing Issues by SleepingSeeker  Rated: T

2. Katana, Kleenex and Karai or When Leo Gets Sick by Tarin2014tfan  Rated: T

3. Snapshots of Time XVIII by hummerhouse  Rated: M

 

Most Intriguing Romance

1. Caro mio ben by AristaStarfyr  Rated: E

2. Gates of Summer by theherocomplex  Rated: T

3. I'll Find You by justpeachee  Rated: T

 

Most Interesting Dark Fiction

1. Fixing Donnie by lukeyandlou  Rated: M

1. Stranger Under My Skin by jkathurricane2813  

2. Logic of the Soul by Poetique823  Rated: T

3. The Incident by DuzMachines1984

 

Most Heartbreaking Tragedy

1. You Can Always Come Home by HannahCake310  Rated: T

2. Unbreakable by Americanpsycho  Rated: T

3. Gates of Summer by theherocomplex  Rated: T

3. Holding You Up by Tarin2014tfan  Rated: E

 

Most Disturbing Horror

1. Fixing Donnie by lukeyandlou  Rated: M

2. Candles Drowning by Goblin Cat KC  Rated: M

2. When the Scientist Becomes the Subject by ChickInRed and Ikara  Rated: E

3. The Thirteen Days of Halloween -Day 6: Candy by Zelgadiss55  Rated: PG

 

Most Interesting Crossover

1. Don's Guide to the Galaxy by FirebirdScratches and turtle-sketches  Rated: M

1. Fifty Shades of Green (TMNT Fanfic) by redwritingdesk  

2. Cold Fire Rising 4: Crossfire by BrightLotusMoon  Rated: T

2. The Thirteen Days of Halloween -Day 6: Candy by sampsonknight  Rated: T

3. No 3rd place because not enough nominated stories

​

Most Compelling AU

1. So, I guess... we all have issues. By SpectrumWriting Rated: T

2. Fog Catchers by Reader115  Rated: M

3. Gates of Summer by theherocomplex  Rated: T

​

​

EROTICA

 

Sexiest Leonardo

1. Provocation by hummerhouse  Rated: E

2. Bits n’ Pieces by AristaStarfyr  Rated: E

3. Candles Drowning by Goblin Cat KC  Rated: M

3. The Other Side of the Door by Koalagriton  Rated: M

 

Sexiest Raphael

1. Double Trouble by hummerhouse  Rated: E

2. When I Grow Up... by AristaStarfyr  Rated: M

3. Keeping Leo by Reader115  Rated: M

 

Sexiest Donatello

1. Beck and Call by hummerhouse  Rated: E

2. Incentive Pay by hummerhouse  Rated: E

3. The taming of brothers and training of lovers by ChickInRed and Ikara  Rated: E 

 

Sexiest Michelangelo

1. Thirst by hummerhouse  Rated: E

2. Leo/Mikey Prompt Challenge by babygirl127  Rated: E

3. Eager Exercises, A Donnie x Mikeyfanfic by bbbuuu

 

Most Sensual Canon Character

1. Nightfall by Koalagriton (Casey Jones)  Rated: M

2. Sins, Debts, Years, and Foes by Illusionna (Shredder)  Rated: M

3. The Things We Do by Andrea O’Down (April)  Rated: M

 

Spiciest Kink Or Fetish

1. Bits n’ Pieces by AristaStarfyr  Rated: E

2. Haze by Peachee  Rated: E

3. To Give by (orphan_account)  Rated: E

 

Hottest Hetero

1. Her Decision by hummerhouse  Rated: M

2. Mutual Agreement by AlessandraDC  Rated: E

3. Good Boy by Gemi  Rated: M

 

Steamiest Slash/Femslash

1. Completely Casual by SpectrumWriting  Rated: T

2. The Things We Do by Andrea O’Down  Rated: M

3. Carrot Salad by LINtmnt  Rated: M

3. The Other Side of the Door by Koalagriton  Rated: M

 

Hottest Group

1. It takes two to tango, but three make a party. by SpectrumWriting  Rated: T

2. Muted Contact by Reader115  Rated: M

2. Settling the Clan by hummerhouse  Rated: E

3. A Fangirl’s Dream by RandomMel85  Rated: M

3. Primal Instincts by autumndragon209  Rated: M

 

Most Turtle-Tastic T-Cest

1. Beck and Call by hummerhouse  Rated: E

2. Caro mio ben by AristaStarfyr  Rated: E

2. Fog Catchers by Reader115  Rated: M

2. Side Affects of Love and Lust by CelticKitsune  Red: E

3. Fifty Shades of Green (TMNT Fanfic) by redwritingdesk

3. For as Long as You Need Me by AristaStarfyr  Rated: E

 

Spiciest Meta-Post

1. Anatomy lesson by Sakycchan 

2. I’m Just Gonna Leave this Here by Sexual Bara Turtles  

3. Please Don’t Call It technically IncestBecause It’s Not by Evento Horizon

 

Most Intriguing Fan Comic

1. Let’s go hunting by NeatTea 

2. Disclosure by P-JoArt 

3. Journal by Sakycchan & Ninjazure  

3. Magnet by MsObscure, script by Dashtumbles 

​