Butter Lovin’, Had Me a Blast by NiefThing
 

Donnie's got a little something left over after their run in with Meat Sweats. Rated: M

==========

​

Lost Among the Bell Flowers by Sundayeyes

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

Michelangelo had never been known to stay in one place for very long. Taverns and street corners were his hearth and home, because roots can't take hold if you just keep moving, and why would anyone want to sink into the ground so deep that you got stuck?

​

They were smart words to live by, and had done a good job of keeping him happy enough. At least until the day he was invited to the sprawling estate of the Hamato Clan, and his entire life was turned upside down. Rated: M

​

Reader: Well written, sexy romance, fun, good world building.

==========

​

Scent by BerryCoffeeCake
 

Mikey has a moment in the kitchen with Donnie. Leo's meditation is interrupted. Rated: M

==========

​

We Hold Our Dreams Close To Our Hearts by AristaStarfyr 

​

The time's come, spring is here and nothing is going to stand in the way of creating hope for the future. At least, that's what Nature says.... Rated: E

​

From Reader: Alpha and Omega, Mpreg, TCEST, babies!  All sorts of tearing out your heart fun along with learning how to court your brother to be your mate.

==========

​

Past to Present by crabapplered 

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Takes place during the ep "Same as it Never Was."

​

Years after his mysterious disappearance, Donatello has been returned to his brothers. Leonardo can't quite believe it, has to prove it to himself with sound. Smell.

​

Touch. Rated: E

==========

​

Candles Drowning by GoblinCatKC 

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Altered beyond his own understanding, Leonardo hides the changes forced on him, struggling not to harm his brothers. But vampires are possessive creatures, and brothers who disobey walk a dangerous line. Rated: M

==========

​

Hiding in Sunlight by Goblin Cat KC

​

Leonardo wakes up on the farm not knowing how he was injured. Worse, his siblings refuse to tell him. He struggles to remember the past few days while knowing this isn't the first time he's made himself forget. OT4. Rated: T

==========

​

A Little Poetry in the Night by Goblin Cat KC

​

Summary: Ficlet. The guys indulge in a little poetry on the barn roof at night. Turtle OT4. Again written for the flamer who insists on me writing more ficlets. Rated: T

==========

​

Casting Stones at the River by GoblinCatKC

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

How long do mutant turtles live? Potentially thousands of years. An exploration of how the turtles discover and then deal with suddenly expanded lifetimes. (This is a series of 100 short pieces in the same story, told out of chronology.) Rated: M – Contains other pairings

==========

​

Does Machines by GoblinCatKC
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Michelangelo and Raphael have to drag Leonardo into the lab, fighting to get him under control while Donatello watches in anticipation of the night's experiment. Donatello needs a clock, and he can force his brother to serve as a delightful time piece. Rated: E

==========

​

Precious Lies by (orphan_account)

​

Donatello has his sex swapped by the Kraang. When his brothers realize, they can't help but take advantage of the opportunity. Rated: E

==========

​

Passion, Love, Lust, and Desire – Chapter 4: Warm Honey by MizMoMo

​

Yeah, we all know Raph is sexy.... Somebody else is starting to think so too... Rated: E

==========

​

Birthday by keep_me_posted

​

Mikey comes up with a special way to celebrate this special day. Rated: M

==========

​

Let’s Have Some Fun by keep_me_posted

​

April helps the turtles act on their true feelings for each other. Rated: E

==========

​

No More Secrets by keep_me_posted

​

One by one, the brothers find out what Donnie's been keeping from them. Rated: E

==========

​

Never Have I Ever by keep_me_posted

​

The brothers come up with a fun way to get Leonardo to reveal his true feelings. Rated: M

==========

​

Mirror by keep_me_posted

​

Unlike his brothers, Donnie doesn't have a unique personality that's reflected in the bedroom. Rated: M

==========

​

Underwater by unluckyduckie

​

The cement thrummed under Michelangelo's wheels. He rode along a shallow channel of rainwater runoff and garbage. Other than the rushing of the water, he was alone with his thoughts. Rated: M

==========

​

Ya wanna challenge by darkkateri

​

Things get a little sticky down in the lair, when Donatello realizes that all his brothers have their sights set on the same thing. Leo. Too bad the leader is clueless. Rated: M

==========

​

First Day of Spring by Applepye

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

It is the first day of spring and the Turtles are driven to mate. Donatello's three, more dominate brothers demand more out of him than he can handle. Fortunately Splinter is there to keep him safe. Rated: E

==========

​

UnExpected Season: Startled, Despirited, Anxious, Denial by CoffeeCakes26, Prophetella

​

Leonardo finds Donatello in a daze late at night. When asked he allows the genius to finish the night in his room. What starts as innocent brotherly concern ends up as nothing innocent at all! Raphael and Michelangelo may have something to say about the L/D night. How did Don get this way-- we didn't care! But, we came up with plausible explanations. Rated: E

==========

​

Left Out by fiction_enthusiast_1990

​

_Arc 1 (Chapter 1 - 11): The relationships among the turtles have grown to be closer after Donnie's revelation that they are not bound by blood. As three turtles in the lair act on their instincts, one is left to wallow in the darkness.
_Arc 2 (Chapter 12 - ?): While the relationships between the turtles take a turn for the better, everything else outside the lair starts to spiral out of control as Stockman's desire to regain his lost humanity gives birth to new and mysterious evils - ones that even the mad scientist himself cannot fully control. Rated: E

==========

​

A Good Morning by Tarin2014tfan

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

In the early morning, Leo contemplates his new lover. Rated: E

==========

​

My Best Friend by Tarin2014tfan
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Raph reflects on his brother on his birthday. Rated: M

==========

​

Best Laid Plans by orphan_account

​

"You don't have to pretend you love me to make me feel better." Rated: T

==========

​

Two’s Company Four’s a Crowd by cndrow

​

Leo and Mike stumble into an awkward relationship; Raph freaks out, Donnie finds it highly amusing. But what are Raph and Don supposed to do when it seems this isn't just a fling? Warning: eventual tcest; LeoxMike, RaphxDon Rated: M

==========

​

Operation S.E.X. by Nike

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Mikey wants Leo and Raph to join him and Don. Leo and Raph want to join. They just don’t know it yet. Good thing Mikey has a plan. Rated: NC-17

==========

​

Lay It On Me by Jordan Herbert aka aloneindarknes7

​

“Look at how good he is at performin’ fer us.”  OT4 Rated: E

==========

​

Operation: Nameless by Jordancatgirl7 (Alonedarknes7)

​

This was originally written and posted on March 31st, 2008 on Livejournal. Rated: T

==========

​

Operation: Foursome by Jordancatgirl7 (Aloneindarknes7)

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

This was originally written and posted March 8th, 2009 on Livejournal. Rated: M

==========

​

I Saw Mommy and Daddy Kissing by Dark Closure

​

Poor Splinter.  Splinter wasn't an idiot. How could he be when he managed to survive for 18 years with four children that got themselves into more trouble than crack addicted movie stars and politicians? Rated: G

==========

​

Burning Jealousy by Kiraynn

​

Raph never realized how much he wanted Leo, until he caught him with Mikey. Rated: E

==========

​

Heat Cycle by Kiraynn
 

Donnie was the first to hit his heat cycle. Leo's worried about his turn. Rated: E

==========

​

Other by VenusTheMarvelTurtle

​

“Oh, man. Am I dead? Did I die in my sleep? Is this like, Heaven’s waiting room?” Leon gasped, immediately devastated. “No, what? I want a redo!”

​

Spoiler alert: He isn't dead. But between that and apparently being trapped in his own mind with two very angry reflections of himself, Leonardo doesn't know which option is worse. Rated: E

==========

​

Switching Shells by squishyturtlefuckfics

​

An accident forces Donatello and Raphael to swap bodies, and Donatello is having trouble concentrating because of it... Rated: E

==========

​

Dark Side of the Sun by Shanalaa

**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Mikey knows what his brothers do at night. Slash! RaphLeo MikeyLeo dark fic! Rated: M

==========

​

Firstborn by SuuriSakara
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

The curse of the firstborn is that, of anything the four of us are bound to experience, I’m the one to go through it first, and the only one to be alone while doing so. Naturally, handling the unfamiliar is great preparation for being a leader, but as they say, it’s lonely at the top. Rated: E

==========

​

Three Days Later by what_should_i_post_here

​

Donnie finds out about his brothers intimate relationship, but chooses to "watch and learn" before actually joining in. Rated: E

==========

​

Finely Sliced by butterballturkeyofficial
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Raph gets a cut somewhere no one ever wants to be cut and now he can't do much of anything for two weeks. Rated: E

==========

​

Ego Check by butterballturkeyofficial

​

When brute force isn't working to keep Raphael's aggression in check, the brothers try something else. Rated: E

==========

​

Warmer Weather by butterballturkeyofficial

​

Raphael is in heat and doesn't want help despite the fact he clearly needs it.  Rated: E

==========

​

Turtlesutra-The Nature of Love by hummerhouse
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Written for the Turtlesutra Fanbook. Rated: E

==========

​

Control by Squeakertons
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Leonardo. The turtle in control. Always. Except with this brother. Rated: E

==========

​

The Team-Up by Squeakertons
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

The fourth instalment of the Misinterpretation series. The boys gang up to 'capture' Leonardo so they can bring him up to speed on their sexy shenanigans. Rated: E

==========

​

Leo’s Demons by LuckyDeathStar
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

But Leo is dealing with forbidden feelings. Rated: M

==========

​

Don’t put your pantyhose in a twist! by Caroaimezoe
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

Don makes a discovery in a storage unit that would change his life forever. Rated: M

==========

​

Side Affects of Love and Lust by CelticKitsune
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

​

A series of oneshots, each chapter is another sexy addition to this universe, however it is not a multi-chapter story. Rated: E

==========

​

Raphael’s Chains by Bahamut Dragons
 

Another different this fic has is that it doesn’t have as much story as my usual work does, even though the fic itself has the average word count. I didn’t want to get caught in a storyline, I just wanted to write some sex for once, and so I did. I think it came out pretty good. Some might find it long and tedious, but in the end I do write a lot for myself rather than for others. I did trunk the ending a bit, but it doesn’t feel too much as such and besides, it didn’t cut off from the good portions of the sex. Rated: E

==========

​

Slaves of the Foot by Kamefootninja (Kame630)
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**

 

Leonardo & Raphael were found and raised by the Shredder. Donnie and Mikey were raised by Splinter. Rated: E

 

Reader: This puppy is a sexy, terrifying clusterfuck fully prepared to teach all the good little writers how to really fuck up their characters. Warnings for graphic rape, violence, torture, imprisonment, slavery, and incest.

==========

​

Just Stay Alive You Idiot! by Codeluluchan

​

Mikey and Leo are the only pair who don't seriously fight. The odd argument or disagreement sure, but not a full "said things we'll regret" fight. Then Leo had to go and almost get himself hurt protecting his family. AGAIN. Rated: T

==========

​

Examination: Heat by Bickymonster, Freckled_Sunshine

​

Donnie likes to perform regular medical checks on his brothers, making sure they are all fit and healthy for whatever the future holds. Rated: E

==========

​

Uh… Prison Sex? by Jeegoo
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

Takes place during the episode "Turtles in Space Part III"

Leo has an issue. Mikey enthusiastically recruits Raph and Don to help resolve Leo's little issue. Rated: E

==========

​

Jealousy by Jeegoo

​

Donatello plants the idea of a foursome into Michelangelo's head, and things go unexpectedly well! Of course. Rated: E

==========

 

Number One Fan by Genius_Built
*Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

Leo is a semi-secret Jupiter Jim nerd, and self-proclaimed number one fan of the fandom’s most prolific writer, OthelloVR. So when his flirting lands him in an online relationship with the wickedly smart and handsome Othello, it almost makes it easy to forget his unrequited crush on Donnie. Almost. Donnie never thought he’d succeed in dating anyone, let alone the funny and charismatic Blue; and while the cloaking brooch makes him look like Othello, Donnie’s never been good at lying. But what human could love a mutant ninja turtle anyway? Rated: E

==========

​

After Me Comes the Flood by Genius_Built
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

Donnie hadn’t misinterpreted it, no, Raph had actually told him to stay away from Mikey. His own brother. For no reason.
Well, perhaps not for no reason…
Donnie turned quickly to his computer, typing in the query that had been bothering him since Raph had first mentioned it.
Alligator snapping turtle biology.
Within minutes, his suspicions — and fears — were confirmed.
The water wasn’t just getting to them, it was drawing out all their base turtle instincts.
It explained everything. His brothers' enjoyment of the water, Raph’s aggression, Leo being extra annoying, even Mikey becoming more possessive. His own longing to submerge himself, the building irritation that itched beneath his skin the longer he denied his instincts—
--|
During an intense rainy season, the lair begins to flood, and Donnie is the only one who can keep their home from sinking beneath the waters. It would be a lot easier to manage if the rain hadn't triggered their hindbrains to run wild. Rated: M

==========

​

Love You For Infinity by TheTurtleTitan
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

How do you tell the people closest to your heart that you love them when it's clear that they don't love you in the same way?
Simple answer?
You don't.
But, boy, is that hard to do when you live with them and always want to be by their side. Rated: M

==========

​

hard boiled by leos_phd_in_bratting
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

Leo lays eggs, as it turns out.

He hides it, and deals with the added side effect of overwhelming horniness until he just can’t anymore.

He’s desperate and aching, but, luckily for him, he doesn’t need to venture far to get more than he needs. Rated: E

==========

​

What else do you have recorded? By CherryTreats
**Fan Fiction Competition Winner**
 

Leo is keeping something from Donnie.
And that can't be anything other than a challenge now can it? Rated: E

==========

​